Buy Early & Save 15% with code VDAY25

Plus Free Standard Shipping on $49+

Buy Early & Save 15% with code VDAY25

Plus Free Standard Shipping on $49+

PLATES | PARTY SUPPLIES + BIRTHDAY DECORATIONS

With over 700 paper plates in stock, we have every style, pattern, and theme to match your celebration, from pirates to circus, unicorns to sports, Paris to mermaids. Make your birthday party unforgettable with our extensive selection of party supplies and birthday decorations.

710 Results

Cookies For Santa Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye
Cookies For Santa Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye

Cookies For Santa Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Bright Snowflake Paper Plate SetBring the party this holiday season with this Bright Snowflake Paper Plate Set! Celebrate Christmas in style with this beautiful set of 8 paper plates that combine vMy Mind’s Eye
Bright Snowflake Paper Plate SetBring the party this holiday season with this Bright Snowflake Paper Plate Set! Celebrate Christmas in style with this beautiful set of 8 paper plates that combine vMy Mind’s Eye

Bright Snowflake Paper Plate Set

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Introducing the Scarf Gingerbread Man Shaped Paper Plate from My Mind’s Eye! This delightful festive tableware resembles a gingerbread person, adorned with a green and white striped scarf and red buttons. It’s perfect for adding charm to any seasonal gathering!
Eight gingerbread man cookies, each adorned with green and white striped scarves and red buttons, are neatly displayed in three rows on a Scarf Gingerbread Man Shaped Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye—a delightful addition to your festive holiday gatherings.
Watercolor Tree Shaped Paper PlateThis Watercolor Tree Shaped Paper Plate is sure to light up your Christmas! With its vibrant colors and unique tree shape, it's a must-have for your holiday dinner tMy Mind’s Eye
Watercolor Tree Shaped Paper PlateThis Watercolor Tree Shaped Paper Plate is sure to light up your Christmas! With its vibrant colors and unique tree shape, it's a must-have for your holiday dinner tMy Mind’s Eye

Watercolor Tree Shaped Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Snowglobe Shaped Paper PlateSet your holiday table with these winter wonderland snow globe shaped plates. Featuring a whimsical winter scene these die cut party plates add holiday magic to any My Mind’s Eye
Snowglobe Shaped Paper PlateSet your holiday table with these winter wonderland snow globe shaped plates. Featuring a whimsical winter scene these die cut party plates add holiday magic to any My Mind’s Eye

Snowglobe Shaped Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Elf Scallop Scatter Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye
Elf Scallop Scatter Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye

Elf Scallop Scatter Paper Plate

$8.00

Unit price
per 

Elf Stripe Paper PlateHolly jolly stripes makes these 8 inch party plates perfect to add holiday spirit to the table at your Christmas party. At 8 inches, these square paper plates are a My Little Day
Elf Stripe Paper PlateHolly jolly stripes makes these 8 inch party plates perfect to add holiday spirit to the table at your Christmas party. At 8 inches, these square paper plates are a My Little Day

Elf Stripe Paper Plate

$8.00

Unit price
per 

Dear Rudolph Bus Shaped Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye
Dear Rudolph Bus Shaped Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye

Dear Rudolph Bus Shaped Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Believe Ornament Shaped Paper Plate by My Little Day

Believe Ornament Shaped Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Believe Present Shaped Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye
Believe Present Shaped Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye

Believe Present Shaped Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

The Gatz Dessert Plates by Jollity & Co
The Gatz Dessert Plates by Jollity & Co

The Gatz Dessert Plates

$7.50

Unit price
per 

Le Moderne Dinner PlatesIntroducing Le Moderne Dinner Plates with a two-tone silver and baby blue design. Elevate your dining experience with these chic and modern plates. Mix and match forJollity & Co
Le Moderne Dinner PlatesIntroducing Le Moderne Dinner Plates with a two-tone silver and baby blue design. Elevate your dining experience with these chic and modern plates. Mix and match forJollity & Co

Le Moderne Dinner Plates

$9.00

Unit price
per 

Introducing the Party More Black Stripe Paper Plate by My Mind’s Eye: Featuring vertical black and white stripes, scalloped edges, and a spooky castle emblem in one corner, it’s perfect for creating a spooktacular tablescape!
A young girl in black holds a tray with a Party More Black Stripe Paper Plate from My Mind’s Eye, a black napkin, and a small card. She has braided hair and is wearing a dress with sheer black ruffle sleeves. The background features a gray wall adorned with a spooky castle emblem.

Party More Black Stripe Paper Plate

$8.50

Unit price
per 

Smiling Skeleton PlateTreat yourself to fun and spooky eats this Halloween with the Smiling Skeleton Plate! It's perfect for a Halloween feast, especially if you're looking to get creativMy Mind’s Eye

Smiling Skeleton Plate

$8.00

Unit price
per 

Vintage Halloween Trio Pumpkin Shaped Paper Plate SetKeep things spooky this Halloween with this jack o' lantern party plate set. Featuring 3 unique vintage inspired jack o' lantern designs, these paper plates are all My Mind’s Eye
Vintage Halloween Trio Pumpkin Shaped Paper Plate SetKeep things spooky this Halloween with this jack o' lantern party plate set. Featuring 3 unique vintage inspired jack o' lantern designs, these paper plates are all My Mind’s Eye
Checkered Paper PlateSpooky stories need spooktacular tableware, and these dinner sized scalloped plates are just the thing. Featuring a black and white checkered design they will match My Mind’s Eye
Checkered Paper PlateSpooky stories need spooktacular tableware, and these dinner sized scalloped plates are just the thing. Featuring a black and white checkered design they will match My Mind’s Eye

Checkered Paper Plate

$8.00

Unit price
per