FREE GROUND SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $49

LIMITED TIME ONLY: 10% OFF ENTIRE ORDER WITH PROMO CODE MEMORIALDAY10

FREE GROUND SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $49

LIMITED TIME ONLY: 10% OFF ENTIRE ORDER WITH PROMO CODE MEMORIALDAY10

PONIES & HORSES PARTY SUPPLIES + BIRTHDAY DECORATIONS

Welcome to our magical collection of ponies and horses party supplies and decorations! From adorable plates and napkins to charming cups, we have everything you need to throw a perfect pony-themed celebration. Let our vibrant decorations transport you to a whimsical world of galloping horses and playful ponies. Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, and more!

40 Results

Clear filters
Cowgirl Pattern Paper Plate with cowboy hats, cacti, stars, and horseshoes on a pink background, bound with black spiral wire and accented with gold foil by My Mind's Eye.
Party supplies including a My Mind's Eye cowgirl pattern paper plate, flamingo napkin, pink sunglasses, and other themed decorations on a white background.

Cowgirl Pattern Paper Plate

$8.50

Illustration of a pink cowgirl boot-shaped paper dinner napkin with a decorative star and stripe design on a black background by My Mind's Eye.
Pink themed party table setting with My Mind's Eye boot-shaped paper dinner napkins, plates, and a straw backdrop.

Boot Shaped Paper Dinner Napkin

$8.50

A pink My Mind's Eye bandana paper cocktail napkin with a symmetrical red floral and paisley design, displayed on a black background.
Pink-themed party table setup with My Mind's Eye Bandana Paper Cocktail Napkins, plates, and straw, featuring horseshoe and lily motifs.

Bandana Paper Cocktail Napkin

$7.50

A "Yeehaw Paper Party Cup" by My Mind’s Eye, with the phrase "yeehaw" in red western-style lettering, decorated with stars and a horseshoe, set against a black background.
A vibrant party setup featuring a pink cowboy boot-shaped plate, popcorn, ice cream, Yeehaw Paper Party Cups by My Mind's Eye, and disco balls on a festive background.

Yeehaw Paper Party Cups

$6.50

Rectangular wrapping paper with a pink background featuring a repeated pattern of red candy canes, yellow stars, and the letter "s" is ideal as a My Mind's Eye Pattern Paper Table Runner for a cowgirl-themed party.
Party scene with a pink and rose gold color theme, featuring a "let's go girls" banner, balloons, and a table with snacks covered by a My Mind’s Eye Pattern Paper Table Runner.

Pattern Paper Table Runner

$11.00

Desert Stripe Dessert PlatesParty West
NEW

Desert Stripe Dessert Plates

$7.50

Desert Stripe Cocktail Napkins by Party West
NEW

Desert Stripe Cocktail Napkins

$7.50

Cactus Acrylic Set by Kailo Chic
Cactus Acrylic Set by Kailo Chic
NEW

Cactus Acrylic Set

$34.00

A Ginger Ray Hoopla Cactus Party Game-shaped coat rack with multiple arms and hooks in green color, featuring small multicolored hooks on its edges.
A hand placing a yellow airplane-shaped puzzle piece on a Ginger Ray Hoopla Cactus Party Game stand, with small cacti and colorful confetti on a table.

Hoopla Cactus Party Game

$9.50

Cactus BannerThis festive cactus banner will have you saying "Let's fiesta!" when hanging it as part of your Cinco de Mayo decor. Perfect as an accent on the taco bar table or asMy Mind’s Eye
Cactus BannerThis festive cactus banner will have you saying "Let's fiesta!" when hanging it as part of your Cinco de Mayo decor. Perfect as an accent on the taco bar table or asMy Mind’s Eye

Cactus Banner

$10.50

Fiesta Mini Cactus String LightsTruly on trend, these tropical cactus wire lights are perfect for decorating a Havana party table, putting up in your bedroom and much more. These fairy lights featuTalking Tables
Fiesta Mini Cactus String LightsTruly on trend, these tropical cactus wire lights are perfect for decorating a Havana party table, putting up in your bedroom and much more. These fairy lights featuTalking Tables

Fiesta Mini Cactus String Lights

$7.00

Cactus Shaped Stir SticksCelebrate summer days with this fun set of drink stirrers. Features: Pink stir sticks topped with small pink cacti Durable and disposable. 4 count per package Slant
Cactus Shaped Stir SticksCelebrate summer days with this fun set of drink stirrers. Features: Pink stir sticks topped with small pink cacti Durable and disposable. 4 count per package Slant

Cactus Shaped Stir Sticks

$8.00

Cactus Paper Cups by Party Deco
Cactus Paper Cups by Party Deco
NEW

Cactus Paper Cups

$6.00

CACTUS NAPKINSThese delightful shaped napkins will add some fun and colour to your celebration. They have lovely gold detailing and will add some style to your party table.  Pack Party Deco
CACTUS NAPKINSThese delightful shaped napkins will add some fun and colour to your celebration. They have lovely gold detailing and will add some style to your party table.  Pack Party Deco

Cactus Napkins

$6.50

A disposable paper cup featuring a vibrant desert sunset scene with silhouettes of cacti and mesa landforms under a gradient sky of pink and orange hues, perfect for a bachelorette party - Desert Scene Cups by Party West

Desert Scene Cups

$7.00

A vibrant, hand-painted ceramic plate featuring a desert scene with saguaro cacti, plateaus, a winding path, and a warm, setting sun casting a peaceful glow over the landscape from Party West's Desert Scene Dinner Plates.

Desert Scene Dinner Plates

$8.50

Load more